Integrated Production and Transportation Scheduling Method in Hybrid Flow Shop

Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering

Table 17 Comparison about best makespan on Group 1 with small-size and large-α

Job	Stage	AGV	α	GA	SA	ABC	GWO	MBO	GATS
10	5	2	0.41	611	610	593	613	577	593
		4		471	468	478	480	470	468
		6		469	467	466	466	465	464
	10	2	0.60	1255	1264	1242	1259	1226	1250
		4		940	939	934	945	948	934
		6		914	911	911	923	909	905
20	5	2	0.38	1269	1287	1280	1325	1268	1268
		4		797	792	796	802	796	776
		6		742	742	753	763	738	728
	10	2	0.72	2505	2524	2490	2542	2481	2487
		4		1461	1451	1486	1484	1455	1465
		6		1136	1151	1158	1167	1150	1145
30	5	2	0.45	1965	1986	1964	1973	1941	1929
		4		1067	1113	1100	1123	1091	1084
		6		811	850	838	856	845	816
	10	2	0.67	3908	3948	3912	3950	3928	3975
		4		2279	2291	2287	2294	2236	2236
		6		1732	1790	1782	1768	1763	1784
Number of optimal solutions				5	2	1	0	5	9