Integrated Production and Transportation Scheduling Method in Hybrid Flow Shop

Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering

Table 18 Comparison about average makespan on Group 1 with small-size and large-α

Job	Stage	AGV	α	GA	SA	ABC	GWO	MBO	GATS
10	5	2	0.41	635	620	608	633	596	615
		4		484	474	480	485	474	472
		6		478	472	467	469	466	465
	10	2	0.60	1291	1273	1258	1283	1243	1278
		4		961	950	946	961	954	944
		6		930	918	918	930	917	913
20	5	2	0.38	1312	1313	1297	1334	1287	1293
		4		808	802	807	825	801	796
		6		759	753	758	772	746	732
	10	2	0.72	2540	2548	2512	2555	2498	2506
		4		1492	1495	1495	1495	1467	1490
		6		1174	1164	1176	1180	1167	1155
30	5	2	0.45	2005	1992	1972	1986	1964	1963
		4		1098	1124	1114	1125	1104	1118
		6		848	856	852	859	849	828
	10	2	0.67	3977	4000	3960	3980	3979	4022
		4		2298	2309	2297	2308	2267	2255
		6		1757	1795	1788	1783	1773	1794
Number of optimal solutions				2	0	1	0	5	10